top of page

BARRICHELLO vs. MASSA: SIMILARITIES  AND DIFFERENCES

Barrichello e Massa.jpg

BARRICHELLO x MASSA​

Rubens Barrichello and Felipe Massa are sometimes unfairly labeled "bad" drivers by those unfamiliar with motor racing, yet experts and F1 team technicians regard them as very talented drivers. I consider both drivers to be of a similar caliber, despite their vastly different driving and working styles.

This page outlines the similarities and differences between them.

CAREER BEFORE REACHING F1:

Rubens Barrichello:

  • Five-time Brazilian karting champion (1983, 1984, 1986, 1987, and 1988) he won his first title at age 11.

  • Five-time São Paulo karting champion (1983, 1985, 1986, 1987, and 1988)

  • 1987 South American karting champion

  • 9th place in the 1987 World Karting Championship Runner-up in Brazilian Formula Ford (1989)

  • Formula Opel champion (1990)

  • British Formula 3 champion (1991)

  • 3rd place in Formula 3000 (1992) (lost to Badoer and Lamy)

  • Seven-time winner of the Granja Vianna 500 Miles (1998, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2004, 2007, and 2009)

  • 11th place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2006)

  • 4th place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2007)

  • Desafio das Estrelas champion (2008)

  • 5th place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2009)

  • 3rd place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2010)

  • 4th place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2011)

  • Two-time Stock Car champion (2014/2022)

Felipe Massa:

  • Formula Chevrolet champion (1999)

  • Italian and European Formula Renault champion (2000)

  • Formula 3000 Euro Series champion (2001) (6 wins in 8 races)

  • 3rd place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2005)

  • Desafio das Estrelas champion (2006)

  • 5th place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2007)

  • 3rd place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2008)

  • 2nd place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2009)

  • 2nd place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2010)

  • 2nd place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2011)

  • 8th place in the Desafio das Estrelas (2013)

  • 2024 Stock Car Runner-up (2024)

In F1, Barrichello performed very well with Jordan (1993–1996) and Stewart (1997–1999) and secured a seat at Ferrari. Massa, on the other hand, did not fare as well in 2002 and 2004, but performed strongly in 2005, beating world champion Jacques Villeneuve and earned his seat at Ferrari for the following year.

Rubinho no kart.webp
Massa F Renault.jpg

SIMILARITIES:

F1 VICTORIES:

 

Coincidentally, both drove for Ferrari, both were Schumacher's teammates, both have 11 career victories, and both ended their careers at Williams.

COMPARISON WITH SCHUMACHER:

Michael Schumacher was one of the greatest drivers in history and comparing the German to his teammates, it becomes clear that both Barrichello and Massa performed similarly when measured against the Schumacher benchmark:

Schumacher x Barrichello:

Largadas: 80 x 24 (Schumacher 0.4s faster)

Chegadas: 77 x 27

Schumacher x Massa:

Largadas: 13 x 5 (Schumacher 0.4s faster)

Chegadas: 13 x 5

On average, both drivers were 0.4 seconds slower than Schumacher in qualifying; in other words, aside from Piquet and Nico Rosberg, they were the drivers who came closest to the German.

DIFFERENCES:

CAR SETUP AND TEAMWORK:

Rubinho has stated on the *Acelerados* channel that he prefers a car with a "sharp front end" (understeer), he was regarded throughout F1 as an excellent car setup specialist. This is confirmed by statements from drivers and engineers who worked with him even Schumacher acknowledged the Brazilian's skill in this area, and it was not uncommon for him to copy Barrichello's setup.

 

Rubinho performed at Schumacher's level on tracks that favored cars with a slight front-end bias (Silverstone, Austria, and Monza), as Michael never liked cars that understeered. On the other hand, at tracks like Spa and Suzuka, two circuits that really test a driver's mettle, Rubinho lagged significantly behind the German, except under rare circumstances.

Felipe Massa, on the other hand, made no secret of the fact that he disliked cars with a front-end bias and preferred those with a rear-end bias. When driving cars that suited his style, Massa performed very well and could hold his own against any F1 driver, including Schumacher and Raikkonen during the 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009 seasons, all of whom were considered highly talented.

 

However, when it came to car setup, Massa was not as skilled as Rubinho.

COMPARISON WITH TEAMMATES:

Rubens Barrichello defeated every teammate except Jenson Button and Michael Schumacher. Here are the teammates he defeated:

  • Capelli

  • Boutsen

  • Irvine

  • Magnussen

  • Verstappen

  • Brundle

  • Herbert

  • Hulkenberg

Felipe Massa defeated only three teammates, but he clearly had more capable teammates than Rubinho did. Massa was beaten by Heidfeld, Fisichella, Schumacher, Alonso, and Bottas. Here are the teammates he defeated:

  • Villeneuve

  • Raikkonen

  • Stroll

 

The comparison of Rubinho and Massa against their teammates reveals a performance difference between them, however, we must consider that Felipe Massa faced four world champion teammates (Villeneuve, Schumacher, Raikkonen, and Alonso), whereas Rubinho faced only two (Schumacher and Button). In this regard, Massa had more talented teammates than Rubinho.

BRAZILIAN GP:

Every Brazilian dreams of winning the Brazilian GP; Rubinho never managed to do so, coming closest in 2003 when he retired while leading due to running out of fuel. On other occasions, he was never really in contention for the win.

 

Felipe Massa, on the other hand, had opportunities in 2006, 2007, and 2008 and he seized them. He won twice (2006 and 2008), the only time he didn't win was in 2007, because the team needed to hand the victory to Kimi Räikkönen so he could secure the world championship that year.

DRIVING IN THE RAIN:

Rubinho was a strong wet-weather driver. In his debut F1 season, he put in a sensational performance at the 1993 European GP, ​​even running ahead of the powerful Williams cars at one point, he also secured his first victory in the rain (2000 German GP) by staying out on slick tires while the track was damp.

 

Felipe Massa, on the other hand, alternated between good races (like the 2008 Brazilian GP) and poor performances in the rain, however, he was undoubtedly inferior to Rubinho in such conditions.

Rubinho Alemanha 2000.jpg
Massa Brasil 2008.jpg

Photos above: Barrichello wins the 2000 German GP and Massa wins the 2008 Brazilian GP, ​​both in the rain.

CHAMPIONSHIP BATTLES IN RACE-WINNING CARS:

 

Unfortunately, Rubinho had six cars capable of contending for the title (2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004 and 2009), yet on every occasion, he fell well short of Schumacher and Button. It is worth noting that during the years he performed best (2002 and 2003), Ferrari engaged in team politics favoring the German. ​

 

Felipe Massa, meanwhile, had three cars capable of contending for the title (2006, 2007, and 2008); he finished as runner-up in 2008, losing the championship on the final corner of the final lap of the 2008 Brazilian Grand Prix. ​

 

In this regard, Massa delivered a more solid performance than Rubinho when driving a race-winning car, though he lost the title due to Ferrari's errors in 2008. However, Felipe did not fare as well in cars that didn't suit his driving style, whereas Rubinho performed well in any type of car a factor that should be taken into account.

CONCLUSION

 

Both were very good drivers by F1 standards; Rubinho was better at car setup and development and adapted better to his cars. Massa, on the other hand, was apparently better than Rubinho in cars with oversteer (rear-end instability) but struggled with cars that understeer (front-end instability), as he himself admitted in interviews.

For the reasons mentioned above, Massa did not perform well with Sauber in 2004 or with Ferrari in 2011, 2012, and 2013, but he performed very well with Ferrari in 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2009. Rubinho, on the other hand, managed to perform reasonably well, even in cars that didn't suit his driving style.

 

Both drivers were evenly matched in terms of talent, making it very difficult to say who was better, however, based on what he showed throughout his entire career, I consider Rubinho slightly better than Massa.

© 2021 by Allaboutformulaone. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page